Best Eye Masks For Puffy Eyes

Disclaimer: When readers buy products and services discussed on our site, we often earn affiliate commissions that support our work.

If you lead a busy life and don’t have much time to rest, you may find yourself with puffy, dark circles under your eyes. Obviously puffy eyes aren’t an inherently harmful condition, but they’re certainly a little unattractive, and it’s totally fair if you want to do something about them.

Today, we’ll be looking at a variety of eye masks that you can use to deal with puffy eyes.

Why Should You Use an Eye Mask?

If you don’t know why eye masks are such a great skincare product, allow us to explain.

There are two types of eye masks out there; cooling gel eye masks and medicinal gel eye masks. While both types of masks perform the same function, they do so differently.

Cooling gel eye masks resemble your average sleep mask, with a fabric-lined cover for your eyes and a strap that goes around your head. The mask is filled with a large number of gel beads, which can be cooled in the fridge or freezer to make a chilled mask that can relieve puffy eyes as well as headaches and sinus pain.

In contrast, medicinal gel eye masks are individual patches that you attach directly to the skin beneath your eyes. These patches are infused with a variety of active ingredients designed to provide relief to the affected area quickly.

The benefit that eye masks have over eye creams is that they typically work a lot more quickly.

Product Reviews

Now that you know why eye masks are so great, let’s get right into our product reviews. We’ll be checking out some eye masks of both types and going over what each of them has to offer.

Eye Secrets Collagen & Q10 Patches


We’ll start off our list with these patches from Eye Secrets. These are medicinal patches that are made with:

  • Glycerine
  • Hyaluronic acid
  • Nicotinamide

All of these ingredients work together to help your skin retain more moisture and make it smoother and less puffy. The patches are easy to apply and comfortable to use, and you only have to leave them on for about 20 minutes maximum to get the desired effects.

One downside of the Eye Secrets patches, however, is that you only get five pairs of patches per box, and one order of Eye Secrets patches is considerably more expensive than any of the other eye masks on this list.

Cedlize Gold Eye Treatment Mask

Cedlize Under Eye Collagen Patch, 24K GOLD ANTI-AGING MASK, Pads For Puffy Eyes & Bags, Dark Circles and Wrinkles, With Hyaluronic Acid, Hydrogel, Deep Moisturizing Improves Elasticity, 30 PAIRS

Next up, we have these medicinal eye mask patches from Cedlize. These patches are made with 24 karat gold and also contain the following active ingredients:

  • Collagen
  • Hyaluronic acid
  • Vitamin A
  • Vitamin C

Collagen is an essential substance that your skin needs in order to maintain its structure and keep itself firm and elastic.

Compared to the Eye Secrets patches, Cedlize’s patches are far less expensive, and you also get way more of them (30 pairs versus 5).

Purederm Collagen Eye Zone Mask

Deluxe Collagen Eye Mask Collagen Pads For Women By Purederm 2 Pack Of 30 Sheets/Natural Eye Patches With Anti-aging and Wrinkle Care Properties/Help Reduce Dark Circles and Puffiness

If you’re looking for the best deal possible on single-use medicinal eye masks, then you definitely shouldn’t overlook these patches from Purederm. For 15 pairs of patches, you’ll pay a far lower price for these patches than you would for any others.

Some of the active ingredients in these patches include:

  • Glycerin
  • Hydrolyzed collagen
  • Natto gum
  • Papaya fruit extract
  • Beta-glucan

Suprance Green Tea Matcha Eye Mask

Green Tea Matcha Eye Mask by SUPRANCE - Under Eye Patches Treatment for Dark Circles, Eye Bags, Puffiness - Anti-Wrinkle With Hyaluronic Acid and Collagen - 30 Pairs/60 Pcs.

This eye mask is made with a simple formula of just four natural ingredients. These are:

  • Hydrolyzed collagen
  • Hyaluronic acid
  • Vitamin E
  • Green tea extract

Green tea extract, in particular, is great for your skin because it contains plenty of antioxidants, which help keep your skin healthy by preventing your skin cells from being damaged by free radicals.

Grace & Stella Eye Mask

Grace & Stella Under Eye Mask for Dark Circles and Puffiness | Gold Under Eye Gel Patches to Reduce Puffy Under Eye Bags (24 Pairs)

These eye patches from Grace & Stella are another solid option if you’re looking for an effective medicinal gel eye mask. These patches are made with vegan ingredients and are free from parabens (substances that can potentially disrupt your normal hormonal function).

These patches also use a very simple list of ingredients, which contains the following:

  • Plant-based collagen
  • Rose oil
  • Vitamin C
  • Hyaluronic acid

These patches are fast-acting, and you should look and feel noticeably better within 15 minutes of applying them.

NEWGO Cooling Eye Mask

NEWGOCooling Eye Mask Gel Eye Mask for Puffiness Reusable Cold Eye Mask with Gel Bead for Hot Cold Therapy, Headache, Migraine, Stress Relief - Green

Let’s move on from medicinal gel masks and go over a few cooling gel masks. We’ll start off with a look at this eye mask from NEWGO.

This mask is made with gel beads, water, and glycerin encased in PVC, with a fabric backing side so that the mask is comfortable over your eyes. The PVC is double-sealed to ensure that none of the liquid inside the mask ever leaks out.

You can cool the mask by leaving it in the freezer for two hours or so, which makes it effective at treating puffy eyes as well as headaches, or you can throw the mask in the microwave for ten seconds if you want to use this mask as a hot compress.

Optix 555 Gel Eye Mask

Gel Eye Mask with Eye Holes- Hot Cold Compress Pack Eye Therapy | Cooling Eye Mask for Puffy Eyes, Dry Eyes, Headaches, Migraines, Dark Circles, Sinus - Reusable Eye Face Mask | Ergo Gel Bead (Pink)

This eye mask from Optix 55 is basically the same as any other cooling gel mask, with one notable exception; it actually has holes for your eyes.

Obviously this makes the mask somewhat less effective if you intend to use your eye mask as a sleeping mask. But the upside is that you can wear the mask, get the full cooling/heating effect you want, and still see out of it.

Brownmed Compression Mask

IMAK Compression Pain Relief Mask and Eye Pillow, Cold Therapy Headache, Migraine, Sinus Pain, Patented, Universal Size

If you’re looking for a slightly more upscale cooling eye mask, this compression mask from Brownmed could be what you need.

This mask is wrapped in a breathable cotton material, and its contouring prevents the mask from exerting direct pressure on your eyes, meaning that it’s extremely comfortable to use.

It’s excellent at blocking out light, meaning you can use it as a sleeping mask too. Perhaps the only downside to this mask is that while it can be cooled, it doesn’t appear as though it can be heated.


If you’re looking for an eye mask to help you treat puffy eyes, you’re certainly not limited in terms of choice. There are plenty of options out there, and all of them are ever so slightly different.

In general, if you want a non-medicinal mask that you can reuse over and over, then a cooling gel mask is probably the choice for you. Otherwise, if you want a mask that uses active ingredients to treat puffy eyes, then go with a medicinal gel eye mask.

Hopefully, we’ve helped you take some of the guesswork out of finding the best eye mask for your needs!

About Nellie

Hi, I'm Nellie! Nice to virtually meet you. I write articles to help people take great care of their skin. I also like to occasionally share my honest opinions on skincare products I've tried or know will help you.

Leave a Comment